dcsimg
A Flash Developer Resource Site

Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: My AS coursework, please give feedback, I need at least 10 people :)

  1. #1
    zephyr Olly K's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    The Univerity of Wales, Newport
    Posts
    1,357

    My AS coursework, please give feedback, I need at least 10 people :)

    Ok firstly thanks for taking you time!
    I've made a site for my graphics courswork, it's a combination of Flash anfd HTML pages located here:
    http://thering.fizz.nu

    I need at least 10 people just to quickly go through the site and fill in this simple questionnaire, it's only 11 questions, please just dlelte the choices as appropriate
    thanks! I really appreciate this, I need it by tommorow so I can analyse the results and draw my evaluation .

    P.S,the pre-loader soesn't work on all browser you may need to right click and play

    Questionnaire
    Please fill in this simple questionnaire by choosing one of the options for each question. Thank you!

    1. What did you think of the initial splash page?
    It gave a good impression,
    Average,
    I didn't pay much attention to it,
    It lets the site down

    2. What did you think about the site opening on a separate page?
    I though it was great,
    I didn't really think about it,
    I didn't like it

    3. How long did the site take to load?
    Not long at all,
    Average,
    It was very slow

    4. What speed Internet connection do you have?
    56k dial-up,
    Broadband,
    Cable,
    Cable Broadband

    5. What did you think of the Flash™ animation?
    I enjoyed it very much,
    I thought it was good,
    Average,
    Could have been better,
    I disliked it

    6. What did you think of the colour scheme?
    I liked it,
    I neither liked nor disliked it,
    I disliked it

    7. What did you think about the site content?
    It was great,
    Fairly Good,
    Average,
    Pretty Poor

    8. What did you think about the menu system and navigation?
    Good and Easy to Use,
    Awkward until you got used to it,
    Very Difficult

    9. What did you think of the site's graphics and logo?
    I liked them a lot,
    I thought they were good,
    Average,
    I didn't really enjoy them,
    I disliked them
    10. How often would you consider re-visiting the site?
    Every Day,
    Regularly,
    Often,
    Occasionally,
    Never

    11. If Never Then Why Is This?
    I didn't like the site,
    I didn't think much of the content,
    I don't like Lord Of The Rings,
    I was too slow to load,
    Other (please state reason if this is your choice)

    Thank you for taking your time!
    - I made this!
    http://www.okkle.co.uk - creatures, art, animation and toys!
    Toilet Trumps

  2. #2
    Senior Member Ex-Ess's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2002
    Location
    York (England)
    Posts
    588
    1. What did you think of the initial splash page?
    Average,

    2. What did you think about the site opening on a separate page?
    I didn't really think about it,

    3. How long did the site take to load?
    It was very slow

    4. What speed Internet connection do you have?
    Broadband,

    5. What did you think of the Flash™ animation?
    Could have been better,

    6. What did you think of the colour scheme?
    I neither liked nor disliked it,

    7. What did you think about the site content?
    Average,

    8. What did you think about the menu system and navigation?
    Good and Easy to Use,

    9. What did you think of the site's graphics and logo?
    I thought they were good,

    10. How often would you consider re-visiting the site?
    Never

    11. If Never Then Why Is This?
    Other (please state reason if this is your choice)
    - It never goes past the loader unless you right click and select play.
    - Broken links on site
    - Flash fonts used but not properly (not on whole number co-ords)

  3. #3
    dIgital pHoto dude! TheEnigma's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2000
    Location
    Maastricht, The Netherlands.
    Posts
    1,101

    Re: My AS coursework, please give feedback, I need at least 10 people :)

    1. What did you think of the initial splash page?
    Average,


    2. What did you think about the site opening on a separate page?
    I didn't like it - neither do i like JS kidnapping my browser and removing menu bars

    3. How long did the site take to load?

    It was very very slow
    Although that is prolly my ISP
    4. What speed Internet connection do you have?
    56k dial-up, conected at 42667bps using 0800dial FRIACO at 0400hrs

    5. What did you think of the Flash™ animation?
    I enjoyed it very much,
    I thought it was good,
    Average,
    Could have been better,
    I disliked it

    6. What did you think of the colour scheme?
    I disliked it
    Hard to read with that type face
    7. What did you think about the site content?
    It was great,
    Seeing as I am into citadel myself
    8. What did you think about the menu system and navigation?
    Good and Easy to Use,
    Make it stand out more though

    9. What did you think of the site's graphics and logo?
    I thought they were good,

    10. How often would you consider re-visiting the site?

    Often,


    11. If Never Then Why Is This?
    N/A
    Been a while since I was here! Might just stay around this time! | Check out my Deviations - all comments welcomed!


  4. #4
    FK's Wave Pimp kamyab's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Orange County, CA
    Posts
    1,210

    Re: My AS coursework, please give feedback, I need at least 10 people :)

    1. What did you think of the initial splash page?
    Average,

    2. What did you think about the site opening on a separate page?
    I didn't really think about it,

    3. How long did the site take to load?
    It was very slow

    4. What speed Internet connection do you have?
    Cable,

    It took way too long to load. I gave up on it after the first three minutes. Sorry. I'll edit this post if it loads some other time.

  5. #5
    dude Jammin-D's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2001
    Location
    Kent, England
    Posts
    334
    1. What did you think of the initial splash page?
    I didn't pay much attention to it,

    2. What did you think about the site opening on a separate page?
    I didn't really think about it,


    3. How long did the site take to load?
    It was very slow - made coffeé came back and it was still loading, gave up and right clicked to play ( i think you may have an actionscript problem mate!)

    4. What speed Internet connection do you have?
    1mb Broadband - Blueyonder

    5. What did you think of the Flash™ animation?
    Could have been better,


    6. What did you think of the colour scheme?
    I neither liked nor disliked it,


    7. What did you think about the site content?
    Average,


    8. What did you think about the menu system and navigation?
    Didnt try as the line art cluttered the page and started to make me sick.. sorry

    9. What did you think of the site's graphics and logo?

    I didn't really enjoy them

    10. How often would you consider re-visiting the site?
    Never, sorry but the site didnt really appeal to me even though im into lord of the rings and used to work in games workshop!

    11. If Never Then Why Is This?
    I didn't like the site,
    I was too slow to load,

    The Line art graphics didnt do anything for the site except clutter it up. I dont think you chose an appropriate colour scheme for your site in ratio to its content, lord of the rings and games workshop stuff in my opinion should be dark and mysterious colours and for a page which should be more friendly then chuck in some grassy green for the effect.
    Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited, Imagination encircles the world.

  6. #6
    Senior Member Lyra's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2001
    Location
    South Africa
    Posts
    243
    I could only answer the first 4 questions as I have waited now for 10 minutes and the site is still loading... will try later again.

    1. What did you think of the initial splash page?

    It lets the site down

    2. What did you think about the site opening on a separate page?

    I didn't really think about it,


    3. How long did the site take to load?

    It was very slow

    4. What speed Internet connection do you have?
    56k dial-up,

  7. #7
    Senior Member Lyra's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2001
    Location
    South Africa
    Posts
    243
    OK, now its loaded, but I see no site, no navigation, just a bunch of lines. Nothing to click on. Am looking at this with a Mac, not my favourite medium, might be the problem?

  8. #8
    dude Jammin-D's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2001
    Location
    Kent, England
    Posts
    334
    It seems to me mate that you definatly have an actionscript problem, cos looking back at the site. the stuff on there shouldnt take 10 minuts to load, not even a site has intense as neostream or whos we take this long.

    You should check that out!
    Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited, Imagination encircles the world.

  9. #9
    zephyr Olly K's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    The Univerity of Wales, Newport
    Posts
    1,357
    Oh ok, I'll check that out, it's not jsut the pre-loader thing is it? I've not got the hang of them yet, you may need to right click it and select play

    Thank you for all the feedback so far!
    -Olly

    - I made this!
    http://www.okkle.co.uk - creatures, art, animation and toys!
    Toilet Trumps

  10. #10

    Re: My AS coursework, please give feedback, I need at least 10 people :)

    1. What did you think of the initial splash page?

    Average

    text layout is perhaps a bit clumsy, but illustration behind knocked out in white is nice... would be cool to see a better relationship between text/text box and image


    2. What did you think about the site opening on a separate page?

    I didn't really think about it

    very common these days and seems fine to me.

    3. How long did the site take to load?

    Not long at all

    ...that is, I THINK it didn't take long... preloader did not work and I had to use 'play' as instructed.

    4. What speed Internet connection do you have?

    DSL (is that broadband?)

    5. What did you think of the Flash™ animation?

    Could have been better

    the flash animation was a screen-build, right? It was pretty basic.... don't know why the white line illustration went up and left and then re-centered.... Seems like those colored bands are a great opportunity for some sophisticated animation!


    6. What did you think of the colour scheme?

    I liked it

    my favorite thing about the site really... lemon lime!

    7. What did you think about the site content?

    Fairly Good,

    seemed deep enough, given that you have lots of product


    8. What did you think about the menu system and navigation?

    OK (sorry to deviate from your choices)

    it made sense, but it was a bit disconcerting to have main nav separated on the right and subnav all together on the left... would have been nice if the subnav came up w/more relation to main nav

    9. What did you think of the site's graphics and logo?

    Average

    The illustration were nice, but the logo is a bit strange/overly complicated

    10. How often would you consider re-visiting the site?

    Never

    11. If Never Then Why Is This?

    Other (please state reason if this is your choice)

    I'm not in to the product... if this were my kind of thing I might well come back.


    the only thing screaming here is: FIX THE BITMAP FONT... you have to be careful in your positioning to get it sharp, not blurry...
    BINKY

    -- god is in the details, sure, but what kind of god? --

    www.rickmu.com

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  




Click Here to Expand Forum to Full Width

HTML5 Development Center