3 mocks. Need help

[RhameJ]

An actor friend of mine wants a portfolio built. He saw my site and liked the color scheme. Im strugling with whick one works the best.

http://www.solidtorch.com/kevin/main.html Menu font will be smaller, too big right now.

http://www.solidtorch.com/kevin/mock2.html Just a basic slider.

http://www.solidtorch.com/kevin/mock2.5.html Same mainframe except the slider moves horizontal, vertical, and diagnolly.

Which one do you like? Or should I start over. Only about an hour spent on each one, so its no biggy if I do.

Thanks,

Josh

[mikey23]

I definitely like the last 2 better than the first. If I had to choose I would pick the last one cuz it has the a nice green which adds to the character. I really do like the last 2 though.

[mikey23]

I definitely like the last 2 better than the first. If I had to choose I would pick the last one cuz it has the a nice green which adds some character. I really do like the last 2 layouts though.

[RhameJ]

He didnt really like them, owell. He wanted something a little more elegant. He wants siver and gold So I came up with this and I think he is diggin it. Will find out tomorrow.

http://www.solidtorch.com/kevin/mock3.html

[sosamaya]

I like the 2nd better

[sense]

Don't really like the font on that last one.
I also think the silver bars are too straight to fit in with the organic ornaments you use at the sides.

What's up with the ornaments theme anyway. What kind of site is it you are building?

[ryanhome]

I like the first best out of the three, however the sound when you mouse over the buttons at the time is horrible it reminds me of that click from touching an electric sheep fence out in the country.

Please change it then it would be nice

Ryan

[ammaar]

Originally posted by sense
I also think the silver bars are too straight to fit in with the organic ornaments you use at the sides.

I agree. I like the 3rd one in your original post but the buttons look too big. The last one you posted looks OK, but I think it needs a little more work, especially on the silver parts.

[RhameJ]

Thanks for the feedback guys.
They are just mocks. No detail work has been put into any of them, so they are still "very" rough. Just basic ideas to put in his head to get the ball rolling.
I agree on the buttons being to big. I intentially did that to see what his remark would be. It also gives him some ideas to go on.

sense. The site will be for a friend of mine who is an actor. He's pretty fluent in PS, so I told hime to make a basic mock of what he wanted, and I can go from there. Should be interesting to see what he comes up with

Thanks again for the feedback.

Josh