RollCanvas IV (now finished) :: Discussion Thread

ok, ok... stop with the death comments and sketching.

ROLLCANVAS IV IS FINISHED!!

I had planned on doing a double image in the end because I didn't want to abruptly finish with a fade but just decided to end this thing. So it's finished.

Dial-up users... you're just out of luck. All PNG's, some are absolutely huge. And the mistakes... hey there were many, many requests to sort them out but they never were... not on a timely basis. If you want to do your image properly if you see something, or you didn't save correctly... or whatever. PM me or just send the file properly done to gerbick [at] gmail.

And sorry for the week delay. Work ramped up when we had a project get pushed up by a full 4 weeks mainly due to some of the most aggressive scheduling I've ever seen...

Thanks to EVP, big time. I'll commiserate later via with rum dude.

hot damn that was well worth it.

i'm going to have to take some time to get my thoughts together to post a better critique of this.

Wow! So many stunning (and surprising) leaves. Awesome work everyone

Well done folks. Gerbs, thanks a bunch to you and EVP for taking the time to organize this.

So many stunning rolls from the seasoned guys!
Well done all!

Some fantastic stuff in there, guys. The ondraedan, nordberg, ctranter section is particularly impressive. I'm really diggin' the way the grass plain turns into the polar bear, and those ships coming out of the clouds are a vividly evocative and believable depiction of a world where the normal rules don't apply. Great work, people! :D:thumbsup:

wow, this is coooool!
:thumbsup: to everyone.

and thanks for working out EVP & gerbick (and anyone else in between)......

:grouphug:

Shweet stuff dearies. Good stuff everyone. I'd have to pick flashl!ght, zacaboo and nepzap as faves for me personally. Gerbs high five. Next time ( if ) remind me to save in the right friggin format hahahaha. :crazy:

not finished or final, just a starting point

pea3698
best point:cohessive image
worst point:soft/weak composition

pointguard
best point:typography
worst point:sliight blending issues

nepzap2
best point:composition
worst point:compression

Zacaboo288
best point:overall image
worst point:vector'ish' rendering of the girl

carly1979, Dricciotii & TheWaste
best point:composition
worst point:lack of texture/detail

gerbick
best point:idea and execution
worst point:... maybe some slight anti-aliasing on the white outline of the dude? maybe?

lefteyewilly
best point:strong theme/image
worst point:could have had much more to it and possibly worked better

ondraedan
best point:strong image/focal point
worst point:hard horizon to the right of the image doesn't do it for me

nordberg
best point:the leave continuation and texture of the image
worst point:planes and polar bears? just not getting it

ctranter
best point:idea/execution
worst point:... could have done more maybe?

<...> The rest upcoming perhaps?

CI once again i love your roll. amazing.

really from ond all the way up till squidlips image just an amazing set of transitions.

Great work everyone. I say Honourable Mention goes to Noiselab. What a great piece.

Great job guys.

Quote:

---

I say Honourable Mention goes to Noiselab. What a great piece.

---

Seconded. Dude, your piece just rocks.

Thank you guys :) ! I wish I was on a little more in the arena, but I'm trying to piece together a few things for a "show tell" type of deal that i could stick in my portfolio, been burried Photoshop lately, trying to come up with something new and fresh.

*currently speechless*

I'm speechless, this is amazing.

gerbs EVP thank you guys for your hard work.