Logo Design - What's your opinion? (merged)

[gerbick]

Those are better than your original outing - why is there a second thread about this, btw!? - but as it stands, a lot of those don't really push or create a label, imho.

Some are good, and like HR said... some remind me of Jordache jeans.

[DaVulf]

Agreed. This is the problem with what ended up happening. I thought someone would come up with something innovative and different, but they all look fairly rehashed.

I don't know which one to pick. :S

[DaVulf]

I'm thinking this one http://www.worth1000.com/web/media/340707/example2.gif .

The top looks better. What do you think?

[sandyrivers]

404 error

[DaVulf]

Works for me..

[silverx2]

i also get 404

[lefteyewilly]

same here

[DaVulf]

Hmm. .Maybe it is a login thing. I'm not sure.

Essentially I clicked on 'View Comments' from the winning entry, and he placed a link to a 2nd version.

[gerbick]

Link to it like you did the others, via the submission ID instead. It's failing for me as well.

That's more than a few people saying so.

[DaVulf]

http://www.worth1000.com/view.asp?en...play=photoshop

It is under comments. He just posted another link, not a submission. If that doesn't work, then try here:

http://www.fashionexclusive.ca/fexexample2.gif

[gerbick]

lefteye's pick to the brush "fx" works the best so far imho. looks a bit like Young and the Restless, but works in an upscale manner if you get the branding consistent and done well.

Again though... and you never addressed this... why two threads about the same damn thing?

[DaVulf]

Again though... and you never addressed this... why two threads about the same damn thing?

The first one was a couple week ago when I was trying to do it myself.

This one was to get opinions after I had it done by someone else .

[gerbick]

Same subject, just a continuation... per the Flashkit rules, merged. In the future, follow proper protocol on posting.

[DaVulf]

My bad. I suppose I just felt that each part was more tailored to a different forum area. CL for opinions, DG for graphics advice.e.

[gerbick]

It's the same thing... you're asking opinions. Just like the initial part of this thread.

[DaVulf]

I suppose it could be seen that way. Just that the CL is normally not somewhere to ask for design advice, while it is where you get the most opinions.

[gerbick]

There's no "suppose" to it. You asked an opinion about a design you made.

Now you're asking opinions about designs that others had made.

If this continues, this thread and any other thread made about this subject will be deleted; just like any other multiple thread creator here at Flashkit, this is your first and last warning about this.

I clear out, merge threads posted by one person about the same subject, multiple times daily. And it sometimes results in a ban because the rules don't seem too clear to that person.

I hope it's clear now. Good luck on your endeavors, don't double post. 'Tis against the rules, you've been here long enough to know much better. And avoiding my original question looks suspicious. You're not above the rules. Nor am I suggesting that you've said/think that.

Follow the rules. Thanks in advance.

[DaVulf]

I understand gerbs, there is no objection here, I was just explaining my rationale .

[gerbick]

And I'm explaining the rules that you ignored.

[DaVulf]

Understood .