What do you this? Rate it from 1to5 :)

[DavidMor]

I designed a site and wanted to get everyone's opinion.
It's all flash, What do you this? Rate it from 1to5

The site is Museum of Moments,
http://www.museumofmoments.com/


Designed by David M.
http://www.davidmoratto.com/

[wemustdesign]

I would give it a 3. Would look much better using a flip book flash movie like this on I have just done, was free to download, easy to customise and is perfect for a book effect like what you are trying to create

http://www.the-lakeside.co.uk/lakeside_menu.html

[rynoe]

I'm gunna give you a 2. This effect has been done, done again, redone, overdone, perfected, reinvented and resurected too many times already.

Only reason I didn't give you a 1 was because if it was the first time I had ever seen something like that I would have been impressed. Keep up the good work.

[whispers]

is 1 good or bad? you didnt state the scale values?

here are the pros I see:
visually it looks 'solid' no crazy color schemes that dont mesh well or anything.. typo looks sound.

intuitive to navigate


Cons:

page flip effect looks 'cheesy'...

the site does really have much 'going on' in ways of interactivity, or anything to keep the user there (customer/user retention).

if 1 is bad..and 5 is best..

Im giving it a 2/3