Another good thing about Gamefly is that you can just buy the games you rented at a decent price. So for games like Madden, that I play throughout the year, I'll put it on my queue and remove everything else right before it launches, guaranteeing that I receive it. Then I just buy it from them for $40 when it ships to me and load my queue back up.

I dont want to tie up my gamefly account with games that I want to keep for half the year.

With rental stores constantly closing around me, I think Gamefly is where its at. I wouldnt have played half the games I have if I had to purchase them. I used to buy at least 2 games a month and with 10-12 hours of playtime for some games, it's not worth it.